Coaching and Mentoring, some people say they’re the same thing, I fundamentally disagree and in this article I’ll argue why. Good coaches and mentors can be expensive, businesses that confuse the process and outcomes of the two approaches will end up wasting valuable time and money with their ladder stood up against the wrong wall.
Before thinking about hiring either, make sure that the individuals involved have an intrinsic desire to improve. Even though Coaches and Mentors are experts at what they do, if there’s no drive from the person receiving the support, both practices could be made redundant. It’s true that some people may need the coachee / mentee ownership model to be explained, but fundamental to the success is curiosity and willingness to explore how this process can massively help the individual both professionally and personally.
This is a topic that could be discussed at great length, but for now I’ll give you 5 distinct differences to help you decide if it’s a coach or a mentor that will help your team progress in both performance and motivation.
Purpose and Focus
Coaching: Typically focuses on specific goals, personal development, or performance improvement within a defined timeframe. The coach works with the coachee to enhance their self-awareness, overcome challenges, and achieve specific objectives. The coach acts in both a supportive and challenging manner, holding the coachee accountable for work in between the sessions.
Mentoring: Focuses on the overall development of the mentee, often encompassing broader aspects of professional growth. Mentoring may involve guidance on career paths and sharing of role specific experience. Mentoring relationships tend to be longer-term, however mentors are often busy people and overloaded with requests of people that want them to be their mentor. Sometimes shorter-term agreements are required to gain commitment from the desired mentor.
Relationship Dynamics
Coaching: Usually involves a formal, structured relationship between the coach and coachee. The coach will provide a program of powerful questions, tools feedback, and support to help the coachee take the action steps they need to achieve their objectives.
Mentoring: Often involves a more informal, nurturing relationship between the mentor and mentee. Mentors typically share their knowledge, experience, and wisdom with the mentee, offering guidance based on their own career journey. The mentor can also open networking opportunities for the mentee with their established list of contacts.
Expertise and Experience
Coaching: Coaches should be trained professionals who use specific coaching techniques, powerful questions, and methodologies to help individuals unlock their potential and achieve their goals. They may not necessarily have direct experience in the coachee’s field.
Mentoring: Mentors are usually individuals who have significant experience and expertise in a particular field or industry. They draw from their own career experiences to help the mentee create resources that will support them. A mentor could be viewed as someone that is steps ahead of the mentee on a similar journey.
Structure and Formality
Coaching: Often follows a structured process involving a series of powerful sessions, with defined objectives, action plans agreed and owned by the coachee to carry out in-between the coaching conversations, and regular review points throughout the coaching programme. Each coachee can bring new topics to explore into the sessions. The coaching relationship is typically initiated for a specific purpose and may have a formal agreement in place.
Mentoring: Can be more informal and flexible, with the relationship evolving naturally over time. While mentoring relationships can have goals, they are often less structured than coaching engagements.
Outcome Orientation
Coaching: Emphasizes achieving specific outcomes, which can often be a mixture of business and personal desires or results within a relatively short timeframe. Coaches work with coachees to set clear goals and develop strategies to reach them, working with the coachee to overcome obstacles whilst developing behaviours and skills on route.
Mentoring: Focuses on the overall development and role specific growth over the long term. While there may be specific objectives, the primary focus is on supporting the mentee’s professional journey based on the mentor’s own individual journey and learnings.
The distinction between coaching and mentoring is critical for your teams personal and professional improvement. Without clarity on their differences, valuable resources like time and money could be wasted. From our experience at Kudos the chance to work with both a coach and a mentor at various times throughout an individual’s career journey is an invaluable way of helping the individual achieve major next step changes in their personal development. Before engaging either, it’s essential to ensure your team possesses an innate drive to improve, this intrinsic motivation is fundamental to the success of coaching and mentoring. By understanding the five key differences outlined, I hope that you can make informed decisions about whether a coach or mentor is better suited to achieving your team’s development objectives.
At Kudos, we’ve built an extensive network of Coaches and Mentors that can be connected with high potential individuals. Contact me at jack@thekudosgroup.com and I’ll help you find the right combination that will skyrocket your team’s performance.
OWN IT 